printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list


Girl Scouts: A Cuter Al-Qaeda

In case you missed your morning dose of crazy, check out the column in yesterday's New York Times entitled "Killer Girl Scouts." Op-ed writer Nicholas Kristof frets: "I've been taking my daughter around the block lately, helping her unload Girl Scout cookies on obliging neighbors - and wondering whether we're killing them."

Kristof's trouble is that some of the cookies sold by Girl Scouts contain trans fats, which he considers such a threat that he laments: "Girl Scout cookies are being sold by cherubs. If the sellers were Iranians with turbans and menacing frowns, then the authorities might be more alert to the dangers." Elsewhere, Kristof alleges that trans fat, as found in Girl Scout cookies among many other foods, kills "far more Americans than Al Qaeda manages to."

So where does he get off lumping Brownies in with terrorists? Kristof cites numbers claiming that 30,000 Americans or more die from trans fat consumption each year. The only problem with this number is that there isn't any science to back it up. The 30,000-plus figure comes from Harvard's Walter Willett (a former trans fat backer), whose estimate is more akin to a back-of-the-envelope guess than a rigorous scientific study.

All things considered, Kristof's broadside against the Girl Scouts is just one more example of life imitating art. In this case, it's our art that he's imitating. Check out our award-winning "Lawyer Grills Girl, Sues Scouts" commercial to see what we mean.

email us comments




printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list

Daily Headlines

  • Hype Masters Call Out Corn Syrup Falsehoods
    Posted On: Thursday 3/11/2010
  • BMI Surveillance: Another Flabby Idea
    Posted On: Thursday 3/4/2010
  • The Golden State Soda Tax
    Posted On: Friday 2/19/2010
  • The Latest Roundup on Roundness
    Posted On: Tuesday 1/12/2010
  • Addicted to Blame
    Posted On: Friday 1/8/2010
  • Back to Make-Believe with Dr. Oz
    Posted On: Wednesday 1/6/2010
  • Fructose Facts Finally Found?
    Posted On: Friday 12/18/2009
  • Grinching Our Diets
    Posted On: Thursday 12/17/2009


  • Activist Cash

    Center for Science in the Public Interest
    Background | Quotes | Financials
    The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) is the undisputed leader among America’s “food police.” CSPI’s joyless eating club has issued hundreds of high-profile — and highly questionable — reports condemning soft drinks, fat substitutes, irradiated meat, biotech food crops, French fries, and just about anything that tastes good. read more here »

    OpEds

    Eat well, but don't skip your exercise
    Unsuccessful dieters and overzealous policymakers might consider that they might have been focusing on the wrong side of the weight-loss equation. read more here »

    Lack of exercise is the problem
    State-by-state obesity trends make more sense when you look at the other side of the obesity equation — physical activity. Simply put, residents of states with high obesity rates tend to move less. read more here »


    Copyright © 1997-2010 Center for Consumer Freedom. Tel: 202-463-7112.