Home / Big Fat Lies / Headlines


November 20, 2008
printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list


Weight Control Is Second-Grade Math, Not Calculus.

Weight Control Is Second-Grade Math, Not Calculus.

There is a buffet of bad information in the news today about what causes obesity. (The economy. Fast food. Television commercials.) Take a deep breath, folks: The truth hasn't changed with the news cycle. Weight loss, gain, and maintenance have always been about the balance between "calories in" and "calories out." Unfortunately, simple addition and subtraction haven't stopped some of the generals in today's food wars from trying to convince you otherwise.

"If your bank account has just tanked, you've lost your job, and you are worried about keeping your house, you're not going to be spending a lot of money on food if you can avoid it," says notorious food cop and NYU professor Marion Nestle. "McDonald's is doing really well now as people have flocked to it, because the cost is low, they know what they're going to be eating, they like the taste of the food, and they're not concerned about whether it's too high in fat sugars and salt."

The problem is that she's blaming so-called fast food when rice, beans, potatoes, and fresh produce are some of the cheapest items at the grocery store. These items are not exorbitantly priced, and they're not inaccessible. They also don't fit Nestle's argument -- so she ignores them completely.

And elsewhere online, the author of a study that erroneously suggests banning food ads will cure childhood obesity even admits that " a lot of people consume fast food in moderate amounts and it doesn't harm their health."

The food police should quit pinning the blame on burger joints and start noticing other factors in our daily calorie math. Dr. James Levine, a professor at the Mayo Clinic, once remarked that relying on modern conveniences, such as washing machines and remote controls, creates a daily calorie surplus of 100 to 200 calories per day. That alone could account for the entire national obesity problem.

"To reverse obesity, we need to develop individual strategies to promote standing and ambulating time by 2.5 hours per day and also re-engineer our work, school and home environments to render active living the option of choice," Dr. Levine now advises.

That's pretty much the same common sense we've been doling out for years. It may not make the same sensational headlines as blaming the economy or fast food for the extra weight around our middles. But then again, since when is the truth so flashy?

email us comments




printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list

Daily Headlines

  • A Godzilla of Corny Hype
    Posted On: Thursday 11/19/2009
  • Toss Out the Myths With the Embalming Fluid
    Posted On: Wednesday 11/18/2009
  • Just “Say No” to Bogus Health Tips
    Posted On: Monday 11/16/2009
  • OJ with Breakfast? Repent!
    Posted On: Monday 11/9/2009
  • Soda Scam Goes Hollywood
    Posted On: Friday 11/6/2009
  • Lawyer Math: 1 + 1 = Prop. 65
    Posted On: Monday 11/2/2009
  • Quote of the Week
    Posted On: Tuesday 10/20/2009
  • More Syrupy Pseudo-Science
    Posted On: Monday 10/19/2009
  • Another Big Sham in the Big Apple
    Posted On: Friday 10/16/2009


  • Activist Cash

    Center for Science in the Public Interest
    Background | Quotes | Financials
    The Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) is the undisputed leader among America’s “food police.” CSPI’s joyless eating club has issued hundreds of high-profile — and highly questionable — reports condemning soft drinks, fat substitutes, irradiated meat, biotech food crops, French fries, and just about anything that tastes good. read more here »

    OpEds

    Eat well, but don't skip your exercise
    Unsuccessful dieters and overzealous policymakers might consider that they might have been focusing on the wrong side of the weight-loss equation. read more here »

    Lack of exercise is the problem
    State-by-state obesity trends make more sense when you look at the other side of the obesity equation — physical activity. Simply put, residents of states with high obesity rates tend to move less. read more here »


    Copyright © 1997-2009 Center for Consumer Freedom. Tel: 202-463-7112.