| More
Home / Press Center / Press Releases


Posted On October 8, 2009
printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list


Study on Menu Labeling Effectiveness: NYC's Battle of the Bulge Falls Flat

New Research Demonstrates Failure Of City's Anti-Obesity Initiative

Washington - Today, the Center for Consumer Freedom (CCF) pointed to new findings published in Health Affairs, a health policy journal, which proves that CCF was justified in its longtime opposition to menu labels. The study found there was no change in calories consumed by New Yorkers after the introduction of mandatory menu labeling in New York City.

The Center for Consumer Freedom was the most vocal opponent of New York City's menu labeling scheme, battling the measure until 2008, when New York imposed what CCF dubbed its "government sponsored guilt" plan. CCF has relentlessly argued that there is no evidence that menu labeling would significantly influence a consumer's choice about what to eat.

"I don't like saying 'I told you so,' but given the city's arrogance in implementing such an unproven policy, it's warranted," said J. Justin Wilson, CCF's Senior Research Analyst. "Menu labeling was never anything other than a state-sponsored guilt complex. New Yorkers have always known the difference between a banana and a banana split.

The study compared a group of New Yorkers to citizens from Newark, New Jersey on how menu labeling affects their decision on what to order. The scholars' research determined that there was no significant change in New Yorkers' calorie intake after the introduction of mandatory nutrition information. The conclusions prove once again that calorie labeling is an ineffective measure to fight the causes of obesity.

"Whether it's menu labeling, soda taxes, or salt shaker bans, New York City regulators seem dead-set on demonizing and regulating more aspects of New Yorkers' personal lives."

The Center for Consumer Freedom is a nonprofit coalition supported by restaurants, food companies, and consumers, working together to promote personal responsibility and protect consumer choices.

For media comment, contact our media department at 202-463-7112 ext. 115




printable version email to a friend join our e-mail list

Ad Campaigns

Food police smashing your choices? Food police smashing your choices?
Everywhere you turn, someone’s telling us what we can’t eat. It’s getting harder just to enjoy a beer on a night out. Do you always feel like you are being told what to do? Find out who is driving the Food Police at ConsumerFreedom.com click to view »

CSPI: The New Bullies CSPI: The New Bullies
Bullies Used To Steal Your Lunch Money. Now They Scare You Out Of Eating. Food cops at the Center For Science in the Public Interest are seeking government control of everything you eat. For a review of their phony food scares, junk "science," and demands for new taxes, visit www.CSPIscam.com. click to view »


OpEds

‘Tis not the season to be annoyingly wary
This time of year, people watching their weight while facing down holiday happy hours and open houses can be particularly susceptible to scaremongering by the fat police. read more here »

High-sodium food fight
It doesn't take a Ph.D. in nutrition to know that a pile of pancakes, sausage, bacon and eggs is not a healthy breakfast. Except, apparently, when it comes to the nutritionists at the Center for Science in the Public Interest. read more here »

Letters

Menu labeling would go better with a side of practicality
Restaurants' creativity shouldn't be limited by published calorie counts or the fear that an opportunistic lawyer will play "gotcha" with an extra dollop of mayo. read more here »

Nanny-state stance seen in health chief
It is unfortunate that President Obama has chosen to put the nation's health in the hands of an overzealous activist who doesn't seem to give any consideration to the importance of personal responsibility or privacy. read more here »

Frieden's views on health responsibility
It is unfortunate that President Obama chose to put the nation's health in the hands of an overzealous activist who doesn't give any consideration to the importance of personal responsibility or privacy. read more here »


Copyright © 1997-2010 Center for Consumer Freedom. Tel: 202-463-7112.